Article

Toll road forecast types

The toll forecasts must be prepared to match the type of toll project delivery being considered.

By Steer

Due to funding shortages, more state and local governments are considering toll projects as approaches to improve their transportation infrastructure, and the toll forecasts must be prepared to match the type of toll project delivery being considered.

So how should the public sector determine which delivery approach to use? Some countries prescribe approaches for undertaking this decision-making process, with Value for Money Analysis or Public Sector Comparators being the most common examples. In the US there is no universal approach yet, although many state and local governments are developing their own methods to address this issue. In doing so, it is important that a properly sophisticated evaluation is used to assess the complex contractual and financial instruments included in P3s. As a key input into the financial valuation, a thorough understanding of the toll revenue is critical.

There are two important considerations of how forecasted toll revenues should be incorporated into these analyses. The first relates to toll rate increases. Publically operated toll roads have a history of modest toll rate increases, with political pressure often limiting their extent. Private sector operators, on the other hand, have tended to exercise their right to increase toll rates subject to their concession agreement constraints. The other important consideration when comparing delivery approaches involves the intended use of the forecasts. Traditional US toll road development is primarily funded by debt issued through the municipal bond market. This offers the advantage of lower interest rates, due to the tax exempt status of the bonds. On the other hand, P3 projects tend to involve a combination of equity and debt investments.

Experience has shown that even on the same project, different traffic and revenue forecasts are used to support the equity and debt investments, because of their different risk and reward profiles. Equity investors will benefit when revenues are higher than forecast since excess revenue net of costs represents their profit. Debt investors do not receive this upside benefit,
although when the public sector develops projects, this excess revenue becomes available to the public for other purposes.

Both debt and equity investors may not receive payment when revenues are lower than forecast. However, since debt payments are higher in the flow of funds than the equity return on investment, debt investors are more likely to receive payment when revenues are less than forecasts, and thus face different downside risks. A robust project delivery evaluation must incorporate these considerations to assess the revenue streams for each type of investment properly. This evaluation must match the likely toll rate increases with the project delivery approach, and align the assumptions included in the traffic and revenue forecasts with the risks and rewards of equity and debt investors.

Steer Davies Gleave will soon begin work assisting the San Bernardino Associated Governments as it considers the delivery approach for managed lane projects in Southern California, and advising the Kentucky Public Transportation Infrastructure Authority in its oversight role of the Louisville Southern Indiana Ohio River Bridges Project.

Off

Subscribe to our newsletter, The Edit

We are Steer

Yes, you are in the right place. After 40 years, we have changed our name from Steer Davies Gleave to mark our growing international footprint and our expanding portfolio into sectors beyond transport.

Explore our new website to learn more about Steer: who we are, how we work and what our future holds.

Related insights

  • 22 Oct 2025
    Article

    Game Changers: The megatrends that will redefine global infrastructure

    Jon Peters
    Associate Director

    Our latest global insight report exploring the forces transforming how we move, power, and connect the world.

    Read more

  • 23 May 2025
    Article

    The influence of state industrial profiles on highway asset valuations in India

    By Steer

    How does a state’s economy and industrial profile impact the value of its road infrastructure?

    Read more

  • 11 Jun 2024
    Article

    Bridging India's infrastructure funding gap by 2025

    By Steer

    India aims for a USD 5 trillion economy by 2025, requiring USD 1.4 trillion in infrastructure investments and diverse funding sources.

    Read more

  • 23 Nov 2022
    Article

    Steer views on the Autumn Statement 2022

    By Steer

    UK Chancellor Jeremy Hunt outlined three priorities of stability, growth and public services as part of his Autumn Statement.

    Read more

  • 17 Feb 2020
    Article

    What is it like to work on one of Europe’s busiest motorways?

    By Steer

    The M25 around London is one of the most important roads in Britain.

    Read more

  • 28 Aug 2019
    Article

    To toll or not to toll

    By Steer

    Tolling has been used to fund the construction of roads since Roman times and toll roads are operational throughout North America today.

    Read more

  • 01 Nov 2018
    Article

    A manifesto for cities’ renaissance in the age of the driverless car

    By Steer

    CAV's linked through big data in a shared economy will become a reality in U.S.’ wealthiest urban environments.

    Read more

  • 21 Jun 2016
    Article

    Road user charging – an equitable solution to budgetary constraints?

    By Steer

    Most countries find it difficult to provide sufficient resources for the optimal maintenance and rehabilitation of their roads.

    Read more

  • 26 May 2016
    Article

    NYC’s 20m creates transportation challenges and opportunities

    By Steer

    New York City is home to 8.5 million people, with the population of the wider metropolitan area at over 20 million.

    Read more

  • 19 Apr 2016
    Article

    Steer Davies Gleave will address the EU parliament Transport Committee on self-driving vehicles

    By Steer

    Steer’s Principal Consultant Roberta Frisoni will address the EU parliament Transport and Tourism Committee.

    Read more

  • 29 Jan 2016
    Article

    Ireland’s N25 road PPP reaches financial close

    By Steer

    On 26 January 2016, the BAM PGGM Iridium consortium reached financial close on its N25 New Ross Bypass PPP in Ireland.

    Read more

  • 12 Jan 2016
    Article

    Easing congestion in Latin America — could lessons to be learnt from Delhi and London?

    By Steer

    Delhi’s experiment with the odd-even number plate scheme is already proving to have a noticeable effect on congestion. 

    Read more